PerformAction
 logo  logo  logo
  • 508-228-6999
  • Sign In / Sign Up
  • Sales
    • Exclusive Listings
    • Search Properties
    • Buyers Guide
    • Market Insights
  • sell with us
  • rentals
    • Search Vacation Rentals
      • Popular Searches
        • Waterfront
        • Rentals with Pools
        • Pet Friendly
        • Close to Town
      • Search By Area
        • Brant Point
        • Cisco
        • Cliff
        • Dionis
        • Eel Point
        • Fisher's Landing
        • Hummock Pond
        • Madaket
        • Madequecham
        • Miacomet
        • Mid Island
        • Middle Moors
        • Monomoy
        • Muskeget
        • Nashaquisett
        • Naushop
        • Pocomo
        • Polpis
        • Quaise
        • Quidnet
        • Sandpiper Place
        • Sconset
        • Shawkemo
        • Shimmo
        • South of Town
        • Squam
        • Surfside
        • Tom Nevers
        • Town
        • Tuckernuck
        • Wauwinet
        • West of Town
    • Renter Resources
    • Homeowner Resources
      • Partnering With Us
      • STR Rules & Regs
        • State Rules & Regs
        • Nantucket Rules & Regs
      • Preparing Your Home
      • Security Deposits
      • Availability & Rates
      • Lead Paint
      • Service Providers
      • Insurance
    • 2026 Owner Rental Updates
  • Nantucket
    • Visitor's Guide
    • Nantucket Areas
      • Airport
      • Brant Point
      • Cisco
      • Cliff
      • Dionis
      • Eel Point
      • Fisher's Landing
      • Hummock Pond
      • Madaket
      • Madequecham
      • Miacomet
      • Mid Island
      • Middle Moors
      • Monomoy
      • Muskeget
      • Nashaquisset
      • Naushop
      • Pocomo
      • Polpis
      • Quaise
      • Quidnet
      • Sandpiper Place
      • Sconset
      • Shawkemo
      • Shimmo
      • South of Town
      • Squam
      • Surfside
      • Tom Nevers
      • Town
      • Tuckernuck
      • Wauwinet
      • West of Town
    • Nantucket Events
  • About Us
    • Our Company
    • Our Agents
  • blog
  • Contact Us
    • Sales
      • Exclusive Listings
      • Search Properties
      • Buyers Guide
      • Market Insights
    • sell with us
    • rentals
      • Search Vacation Rentals
        • Popular Searches
          • Waterfront
          • Rentals with Pools
          • Pet Friendly
          • Close to Town
        • Search By Area
          • Brant Point
          • Cisco
          • Cliff
          • Dionis
          • Eel Point
          • Fisher's Landing
          • Hummock Pond
          • Madaket
          • Madequecham
          • Miacomet
          • Mid Island
          • Middle Moors
          • Monomoy
          • Muskeget
          • Nashaquisett
          • Naushop
          • Pocomo
          • Polpis
          • Quaise
          • Quidnet
          • Sandpiper Place
          • Sconset
          • Shawkemo
          • Shimmo
          • South of Town
          • Squam
          • Surfside
          • Tom Nevers
          • Town
          • Tuckernuck
          • Wauwinet
          • West of Town
      • Renter Resources
      • Homeowner Resources
        • Partnering With Us
        • STR Rules & Regs
          • State Rules & Regs
          • Nantucket Rules & Regs
        • Preparing Your Home
        • Security Deposits
        • Availability & Rates
        • Lead Paint
        • Service Providers
        • Insurance
      • 2026 Owner Rental Updates
    • Nantucket
      • Visitor's Guide
      • Nantucket Areas
        • Airport
        • Brant Point
        • Cisco
        • Cliff
        • Dionis
        • Eel Point
        • Fisher's Landing
        • Hummock Pond
        • Madaket
        • Madequecham
        • Miacomet
        • Mid Island
        • Middle Moors
        • Monomoy
        • Muskeget
        • Nashaquisset
        • Naushop
        • Pocomo
        • Polpis
        • Quaise
        • Quidnet
        • Sandpiper Place
        • Sconset
        • Shawkemo
        • Shimmo
        • South of Town
        • Squam
        • Surfside
        • Tom Nevers
        • Town
        • Tuckernuck
        • Wauwinet
        • West of Town
      • Nantucket Events
    • About Us
      • Our Company
      • Our Agents
    • blog
    • Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up
  • Sales
    • Exclusive Listings
    • Search Properties
    • Buyers Guide
    • Market Insights
  • sell with us
  • rentals
    • Search Vacation Rentals
      • Popular Searches
        • Waterfront
        • Rentals with Pools
        • Pet Friendly
        • Close to Town
      • Search By Area
        • Brant Point
        • Cisco
        • Cliff
        • Dionis
        • Eel Point
        • Fisher's Landing
        • Hummock Pond
        • Madaket
        • Madequecham
        • Miacomet
        • Mid Island
        • Middle Moors
        • Monomoy
        • Muskeget
        • Nashaquisett
        • Naushop
        • Pocomo
        • Polpis
        • Quaise
        • Quidnet
        • Sandpiper Place
        • Sconset
        • Shawkemo
        • Shimmo
        • South of Town
        • Squam
        • Surfside
        • Tom Nevers
        • Town
        • Tuckernuck
        • Wauwinet
        • West of Town
    • Renter Resources
    • Homeowner Resources
      • Partnering With Us
      • STR Rules & Regs
        • State Rules & Regs
        • Nantucket Rules & Regs
      • Preparing Your Home
      • Security Deposits
      • Availability & Rates
      • Lead Paint
      • Service Providers
      • Insurance
    • 2026 Owner Rental Updates
  • Nantucket
    • Visitor's Guide
    • Nantucket Areas
      • Airport
      • Brant Point
      • Cisco
      • Cliff
      • Dionis
      • Eel Point
      • Fisher's Landing
      • Hummock Pond
      • Madaket
      • Madequecham
      • Miacomet
      • Mid Island
      • Middle Moors
      • Monomoy
      • Muskeget
      • Nashaquisset
      • Naushop
      • Pocomo
      • Polpis
      • Quaise
      • Quidnet
      • Sandpiper Place
      • Sconset
      • Shawkemo
      • Shimmo
      • South of Town
      • Squam
      • Surfside
      • Tom Nevers
      • Town
      • Tuckernuck
      • Wauwinet
      • West of Town
    • Nantucket Events
  • About Us
    • Our Company
    • Our Agents
  • blog
  • Contact Us
    • Sales
      • Exclusive Listings
      • Search Properties
      • Buyers Guide
      • Market Insights
    • sell with us
    • rentals
      • Search Vacation Rentals
        • Popular Searches
          • Waterfront
          • Rentals with Pools
          • Pet Friendly
          • Close to Town
        • Search By Area
          • Brant Point
          • Cisco
          • Cliff
          • Dionis
          • Eel Point
          • Fisher's Landing
          • Hummock Pond
          • Madaket
          • Madequecham
          • Miacomet
          • Mid Island
          • Middle Moors
          • Monomoy
          • Muskeget
          • Nashaquisett
          • Naushop
          • Pocomo
          • Polpis
          • Quaise
          • Quidnet
          • Sandpiper Place
          • Sconset
          • Shawkemo
          • Shimmo
          • South of Town
          • Squam
          • Surfside
          • Tom Nevers
          • Town
          • Tuckernuck
          • Wauwinet
          • West of Town
      • Renter Resources
      • Homeowner Resources
        • Partnering With Us
        • STR Rules & Regs
          • State Rules & Regs
          • Nantucket Rules & Regs
        • Preparing Your Home
        • Security Deposits
        • Availability & Rates
        • Lead Paint
        • Service Providers
        • Insurance
      • 2026 Owner Rental Updates
    • Nantucket
      • Visitor's Guide
      • Nantucket Areas
        • Airport
        • Brant Point
        • Cisco
        • Cliff
        • Dionis
        • Eel Point
        • Fisher's Landing
        • Hummock Pond
        • Madaket
        • Madequecham
        • Miacomet
        • Mid Island
        • Middle Moors
        • Monomoy
        • Muskeget
        • Nashaquisset
        • Naushop
        • Pocomo
        • Polpis
        • Quaise
        • Quidnet
        • Sandpiper Place
        • Sconset
        • Shawkemo
        • Shimmo
        • South of Town
        • Squam
        • Surfside
        • Tom Nevers
        • Town
        • Tuckernuck
        • Wauwinet
        • West of Town
      • Nantucket Events
    • About Us
      • Our Company
      • Our Agents
    • blog
    • Contact Us
Email
(508) 228-6999

54 Fair Street, Nantucket, MA 02554

$4,895,000

  • Active
  • Open House
  • New Listing
  • Price Reduced
-1 More Schedule
  • Property Info
  • Photos
  • Virtual Tour
  • Print
  • Saved Save Listing
  • Share Listing
more_vert
  • Property Info
  • Photos
  • Print
  • Photos
  • Virtual Tour
  • Print
  • Request Info
  • 5 BedBeds
  • 5.5 BathBaths
  • 2,538 SqftSqft
  • TypeSingle Family
  • Active
  • Listing # 93365
-1 More Schedule

Property Description 54 Fair Street, Nantucket, MA 02554

Set along one of Nantucket Town's most charming and historic streets, 54 Fair is a beautifully renovated circa-1800 residence that pairs more than two centuries of island character with modern comfort.

Just moments from Main Street, this five bedroom, five and a half bathroom home retains notable historic details, including original pine floors, chair rails and doors. The inviting floor plan offers beautifully appointed living, dining and kitchen spaces, a first-floor en suite bedroom, three additional en suite bedrooms on the second floor, and a spacious private primary suite occupying the third.

Outside, a secluded brick patio, outdoor shower and off-street parking provide exceptional amenities for an in-Town property.

Thoughtfully updated while preserving its historic character, this home offers a rare opportunity to own an authentic piece of old Nantucket just a short distance from the shops, restaurants and cobblestones of Main Street. Offered fully furnished and turnkey, this home presents an opportunity for immediate enjoyment, complemented by a strong rental history that adds to its appeal as both a Nantucket retreat and investment property.

External Links

Video One
 Video One

Thank you for requesting a showing of this property. A representative will be in touch with you shortly to confirm the requested showing date and time.
Please note that your appointment is not confirmed until someone contacts you.

Request More Information

Submit

A welcoming entry opens to bright living and dining spaces, a well-appointed kitchen, and a convenient first-floor ensuite bedroom.

Three comfortable ensuite bedrooms provide private accommodations for family and guests, each thoughtfully updated while maintaining the home’s classic character.

The entire third floor is dedicated to a spacious and private suite, creating a peaceful retreat tucked above the heart of Town.

Crawl space and Mechanicals

Area

Town is the designation given to the downtown shopping and dining district and the surrounding residential areas. For most of this area, your Nantucket Jeep can stay parked at home as you leisurely meander to dining, shopping, museums, Yacht Clubs and more. All ferry boats dock in Town and it's an easy to location to grab a taxi or rideshare from or to. Homes here are, for the most part, close together. The majority of homes have some historic significance and offer some beautiful hidden gardens. Even though these properties are tight together, you will be surprised to find some of the most lush and surprisingly private yards within. And not enough can be said about the ease of access to all the summer fun of downtown.

  • 0 - 0.5 miles to Town
  • All the most wonderful restaurants you could ask for reside in the downtown district. From sandwiches and grab and go to 5-star fine dining, Town is your oyster…or lobster…or steak…or scallops. Whatever you are in the mood for!
  • With everything from T-shirt shops to designer clothing to home goods to souvenirs, shopping in downtown can be whatever you make of it.
  • The Nantucket Whaling Museum is a wonderful place to visit and learn about Nantucket's whaling years as well as the island's history in general. Their exhibits change annually so there will always be something new to see.
  • A summer evening on Nantucket is never complete without ice cream! There are several spots to check out including The Juicebar, Jack and Charlies, and The Counter at Nantucket Pharmacy featuring Island Kitchen ice cream.
  • The Nantucket Boat Basin is a great place to stroll the docks and check out all the yachts and boats in the harbor. You will see some of the most unique sea-going vessels in the world and enjoy the laid back atmosphere.
  • Nantucket and Great Harbot Yacht Clubs are both located in town and are favorite spots for members and their guests for boating, sailing, tennis (GHYC tennis is out of town,) and socializing.
  • There are a plethora of historical sites to check out in the Town area. From the Oldest House, to Greater Light, to the Hadwen House and more, there will be something for everyone. Check out the Nantucket Historical Association website for hours and admission information.
  • Book a fishing, sailing, ice cream cruise, social, or kids trip out on one of the many charter boats along Straight Wharf for out of the Town Pier. Find our favorites listed in our Travel Guide!

community

Property Details

  • Property Type: Single Family
  • List Date: 08/13/2026
  • Year Built: 1800
  • Year Renovated: 2018
  • Area: Town
  • Zoning: ROH
  • Beds: 5
  • Full Bath: 5
  • Half Bath: 1
  • Total Baths: 6
  • Annual Taxes: $11,212.66
  • Tax Year: 2026
  • Water Frontage: No
  • Water Views: No
  • Other Views: None
  • Water: Town
  • Sewer: Twn

Amenities

Interior FeaturesInterior Features
  • Furnished: Furnished
  • Heat: GFHA
  • Fireplaces: 2
Exterior FeaturesExterior Features
  • Private Pool: No
  • Community Pool: No
  • Private Tennis: No
  • Community Tennis: No
  • Hot Tub: No
  • Parking: Yes
Other StructuresOther Structures

Estimated Monthly Mortgage Calculator

Monthly
Payment

    This calculator is provided for informational purposes only by Burrow Services, Inc. You should not make any decisions based simply on the information provided. Values indicated are estimates and may not be accurate and are only to be used as a guide. This calculator should not be relied upon in any way as the sole source of information. Please consult your financial, tax or legal advisers for an accurate assessment of your mortgage payments and any advice relating to your personal circumstances.

    Map View

     

    Market Watch of Town

    Residential

    $4.5M (9.06% )

    Residential

    $4.3M (10.79% )

    Residential

    $4.3M

    2

    44

    SUBSCRIBE TO Town REPORT VIEW ALL MARKET REPORTS EXPLORE Town

    Similar Listings

      • Open House
      • Price Reduced
      • virtual Tour
      • New Listing
      • Coming Soon
      • Pending
      • Leased
      23 Pine Street Nantucket MA 02554
      $5,695,000
      4 BED 4 BEDS 4.5 BATH 4.5 BATHS 2,500 SQ. FT.
      MLS# 90987Single Family
      Listing Courtesy of Lee Real Estate
      Request Info
      Delete
      Details
        • Open House
        • Price Reduced $150,000
        • virtual Tour
        • New Listing
        • Coming Soon
        • Active
        • Leased
        2 Mariner Way Nantucket MA 02554
        $5,299,000
        4 BED 4 BEDS 4.5 BATH 4.5 BATHS 3,438 SQ. FT.
        MLS# 92670Single Family
        Listing Courtesy of JD Advisors, Inc
        Request Info
        Delete
        Details
          • Open House
          • Price Reduced $650,000
          • virtual Tour
          • New Listing
          • Coming Soon
          • Active
          • Leased
          2 Silver Street Nantucket MA 02554
          $5,250,000
          5 BED 5 BEDS 4.5 BATH 4.5 BATHS 3,640 SQ. FT.
          MLS# 91891Single Family
          Listing Courtesy of Fisher Real Estate
          Request Info
          Delete
          Details
            • Open House
            • Price Reduced
            • virtual Tour
            • New Listing
            • Coming Soon
            • Active
            • Leased
            39A Milk Street Nantucket MA 02554
            $5,195,000
            5 BED 5 BEDS 5.5 BATH 5.5 BATHS 4,793 SQ. FT.
            MLS# 93189Single Family
            Listing Courtesy of William Raveis Nantucket
            Request Info
            Delete
            Details
              • Open House
              • Price Reduced $300,000
              • virtual Tour
              • New Listing
              • Coming Soon
              • Pending
              • Leased
              4 Sunset Hill Lane Nantucket MA 02554
              $4,995,000
              5 BED 5 BEDS 5.5 BATH 5.5 BATHS 2,825 SQ. FT.
              MLS# 92709Single Family
              Listing Courtesy of Fisher Real Estate
              Request Info
              Delete
              Details
                • Open House
                • Price Reduced
                • virtual Tour
                • New Listing
                • Coming Soon
                • Active
                • Leased
                47 Fair Street Nantucket MA 02554
                $4,950,000
                3 BED 3 BEDS 4.0 BATH 4.0 BATHS 2,832 SQ. FT.
                MLS# 92897Single Family
                Listing Courtesy of William Raveis Nantucket
                Request Info
                Delete
                Details
                  • Open House
                  • Price Reduced
                  • virtual Tour
                  • New Listing
                  • Coming Soon
                  • Pending
                  • Leased
                  10B Angola Street Nantucket MA 02554
                  $4,295,000
                  3 BED 3 BEDS 3.5 BATH 3.5 BATHS 2,814 SQ. FT.
                  MLS# 92928Single Family
                  Listing Courtesy of Maury People Sotheby's International Realty
                  Request Info
                  Delete
                  Details
                    • Open House
                    • Price Reduced
                    • virtual Tour
                    • New Listing
                    • Coming Soon
                    • Active
                    • Leased
                    42B Union Street Nantucket MA 02554
                    $4,295,000
                    3 BED 3 BEDS 3.5 BATH 3.5 BATHS 2,100 SQ. FT.
                    MLS# 92604Single Family
                    Listing Courtesy of Maury People Sotheby's International Realty
                    Request Info
                    Delete
                    Details
                      • Open House
                      • Price Reduced
                      • virtual Tour
                      • New Listing
                      • Coming Soon
                      • Active
                      • Leased
                      37 Union Street Nantucket MA 02554
                      $4,295,000
                      4 BED 4 BEDS 4.5 BATH 4.5 BATHS 2,554 SQ. FT.
                      MLS# 92547Single Family
                      Listing Courtesy of Atlantic East Nantucket Real Estate
                      Request Info
                      Delete
                      Details
                        • Open House
                        • Price Reduced
                        • virtual Tour
                        • New Listing
                        • Coming Soon
                        • Pending
                        • Leased
                        35 Pine Street Nantucket MA 02554
                        $3,995,000
                        4 BED 4 BEDS 3.5 BATH 3.5 BATHS 2,259 SQ. FT.
                        MLS# 93198Single Family
                        Listing Courtesy of Maury People Sotheby's International Realty
                        Request Info
                        Delete
                        Details
                          • Open House
                          • Price Reduced $600,000
                          • virtual Tour
                          • New Listing
                          • Coming Soon
                          • Active
                          • Leased
                          35 West Chester Street Nantucket MA 02554
                          $3,800,000
                          3 BED 3 BEDS 1.5 BATH 1.5 BATHS 1,920 SQ. FT.
                          MLS# 91936Single Family
                          Listing Courtesy of Great Point Properties
                          Request Info
                          Delete
                          Details
                            • Open House
                            • Price Reduced
                            • virtual Tour
                            • New Listing
                            • Coming Soon
                            • Active
                            • Leased
                            8 East Dover Street Nantucket MA 02554
                            $3,695,000
                            4 BED 4 BEDS 3.0 BATH 3.0 BATHS 1,820 SQ. FT.
                            MLS# 93152Single Family
                            Listing Courtesy of Maury People Sotheby's International Realty
                            Request Info
                            Delete
                            Details
                            Nantucket Logo

                            Address

                            35A Old South Road Nantucket MA 02554

                            Contact Us

                            Customer Service 508-228-6999
                            Copyright © 2026 Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Island Properties Nantucket. All Rights Reserved.
                            • Terms of Use
                            • Privacy Policy
                            • Accessibility Statement
                            • For ADA assistance call 877-788-7746

                            © 2026 BHH Affiliates, LLC. An independently owned and operated franchisee of BHH Affiliates, LLC.
                            Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices and the Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices symbol are registered service marks of Columbia Insurance Company, a Berkshire Hathaway affiliate. Equal Housing Opportunity. All rights reserved. License #: 8291

                            • Comparison List   0